I'm not able to pull off super thick mascara but I do like to use a little and I really like it to stay put. So my choice is Lancome's Defincil's Mascara. This stuff ain't cheap ($15-$20) and I'd love to find something more budget friendly but I haven't yet. I'm able to wear this while working out without getting raccoon eyes and it also does a good job of individualizing each lash. I go for the dark brown, water proof version.
Here's a quick one this week.